Judge Issues Hilarious Opinion Refusing to Seal Docs

By Jenna Greene |

U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer clearly didn’t think much of motions by firms including Wachtell and Skadden asking for documents to be sealed in a suit against Hewlett-Packard Co. How he responded is classic.

Michael Sommer

Litigator of the Week: Michael Sommer of Wilson Sonsini

By Scott Flaherty |

In the Teva-Mylan M&A fight, a preliminary litigation win helped keep a hostile bidder at bay.

Mary Jo White.

SEC Pay Ratio Rule in the Crosshairs, but It’s Not an Easy Target

By Jenna Greene |

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission is all but certain to be sued over rules adopted Wednesday that require public companies to disclose the ratio between their chief executive officers’ pay and that of their median employees. But how likely is a lawsuit to succeed?

SEC Plays Gotcha in Case Against Baby Formula Maker

By Jenna Greene |

Enforcement of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission sometimes feels like small-time, gotcha-style litigation. Case in point: the $12 million settlement with Mead Johnson Nutrition Co. over marketing baby formula to health care professionals in China.

After Failing to Boot Plaintiffs Firm, JPMorgan Inks $388M MBS Settlement

By Scott Flaherty |

For the Robbins Geller lawyers, who could earn close to $100 million in fees for their work, a $388 million settlement with JPMorgan must be all the sweeter since they first had to defeat efforts to disqualify them from spearheading the case.

U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission building.

Kilpatrick Lodges New Challenge to In-House SEC Proceedings

By Scott Flaherty |

The firm hopes to reprise a rare success in a growing trickle of cases challenging the constitutionality of the SEC's administrative enforcement regime.

Ethan Wohl of Wohl & Fruchter. SAC Capital wants the firm to cough up details of its arrangements with outside litigation funders.

SAC Capital Pursues Discovery Over Lawsuit Funding

By Scott Flaherty |

SAC Capital wants to know who's financing a case brought by shareholders of Elan Corp. against the hedge fund.

The former headquarters of Lehman Brothers in Manhattan.

Plaintiffs Strike Out in Lehman Employee Stock Plan Case

By Scott Flaherty |

The U.S. Supreme Court's 2014 ruling in Fifth Third v. Dudenhoeffer may have transformed the pleading requirements for ERISA plaintiffs, but it couldn't save claims against the administrators for Lehman Brothers Holding Inc.'s employee stock ownership plan.

Plaintiffs Ordered to 'Start Over' On Eve of Securities Class Action Trial

By David Bario |

U.S. District Judge Sam Sparks in Austin let a group of lawyers have it this week after he was forced to scuttle a long-planned securities class action trial against drugmaker Pain Therapeutics Inc.

After Third Circuit Win, Wal-Mart Stumbles in the Sixth

By Scott Flaherty |

It's been a big week for Wal-Mart Stores Inc. and its go-to appellate lawyer, Theodore Boutrous Jr. of Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, who got to revel in one long-awaited ruling but suffered a setback in another.

Marc Kasowitz is representing Macquarie Capital in its malpractice case against Morrison & Foerster.

MoFo, Macquarie Square Off in Puda Coal Malpractice Case

By Scott Flaherty |

Macquarie Capital appears to have made peace with U.S. regulators over the messy demise of China's Puda Coal. But Macquarie's fight with its former lawyers at Morrison & Foerster is just heating up.

Cablevision Wins Delaware Ruling on Executive Pay

By Scott Flaherty |

Vice Chancellor John Noble implied he was troubled by some pay decisions at Cablevision, but deferred to the company's compensation committee.

KKR Taps Ex-SEC Lawyer at Debevoise for SEC Fees Case

By Susan Beck |

When KKR faced a groundbreaking investigation by the SEC into its allocation of expenses, it turned to someone who is familiar with the agency’s views on that topic. It hired Debevoise partner Robert Kaplan, the former co-chief of the SEC's asset management unit.

Stanford Ponzi Suit Continues for Chadbourne and Proskauer

By Anita Abedian |

A Texas federal judge has allowed lawsuits to continue against Proskauer, Chadbourne and a former lawyer at the two firms over the roles they played representing convicted Ponzi scheme promoter R. Allen Stanford.

Walter Forbes, former chairman of Cendant Corp.

Second Circuit Rejects Forbes' Bid for New Trial

By Madeline Farber |

Walter Forbes, the former chairman of Cendant Corp. who was given a 12 1/2-year sentence for fraud, argued that he had newly discovered evidence in the form of testimony of a former CFO.

Entrepreneur Slapped by SEC Apologizes, Explains in Video

By Susan Beck |

On the same day that the SEC announced that it had reached a $20,000 settlement with Sand Hill Exchange for illegally running a fantasy stock trading operation, one of the company's young founders posted a self-made video apologizing.

Photograph by Keith Bedford/Getty

Skadden Wins Round for American Apparel

By Scott Flaherty |

Two allies of American Apparel founder Dov Charney have been dealt a setback in their lawsuit attempting to help Charney regain control of the company.

Billionaire Wife's Case Tossed for Failure to Show

By Scott Flaherty |

Real estate mogul Roger Wang's failure to show for a deposition caused the dismissal of a securities case brought by his wife over Bear Stearns' collapse.

RMBS Investors Get Green Light in Megabillions HSBC Suit

By Scott Flaherty |

The decision comes in one of six lawsuits that Bernstein Litowitz brought last year against banks that served as trustees for more than $2 trillion in residential mortgage-backed securities.

Another Securities Case Founders on Confidential Witnesses

By Scott Flaherty |

Relying on informants can help nudge a case past a motion to dismiss—but the practice has become minefield for the securities class action plaintiffs bar.

U.S. Supreme Court building

High Court Won't Hear NVIDIA Securities Case

By Scott Flaherty |

Proving that an apparent circuit split isn't always a ticket to the U.S. Supreme Court, the justices on Tuesday declined to review whether a company's failure to abide by a certain securities regulation can give rise to fraud claims.

Pfizer headquarters in New York City.

Pfizer Fights to Keep Lid on 10-Year-Old Class Action

By Scott Flaherty |

Lawyers hoping to resurrect a decade-old securities class action against Pfizer Inc. will make their case to the Second Circuit on Tuesday.

A Lululemon Athletica store in Chicago, IL.

No Securities Fraud in Lululemon Missteps, Court Affirms

By Scott Flaherty |

The business press may never tire of reminding Lululemon Athletica about its see-through yoga pants debacle. But for the securities class action plaintiffs bar, Lululemon is proving to be an elusive target.

Decade-Old Vioxx Investor Class Action Moves Forward

By Scott Flaherty |

The case, which dates back to 2004, has been pending for twice as long as Merck's blockbuster painkiller was offered for sale.

Philippe Selendy

Litigator of the Week: Philippe Selendy of Quinn Emanuel

By David Bario |

Even if Selendy had lost his landmark securities trial for the Federal Housing Finance Agency, it would be hard to call the FHFA's litigation campaign against Wall Street anything but a victory. But boy, did he ever win.

Goldman Loses $100M FINRA Ruling as CDO Headaches Rage On

By Scott Flaherty |

In yet another dispute alleging that Goldman Sachs marketed a CDO that it was wagering would fail, a FINRA panel sided with the bank's adversaries at Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan.

Quinn Emanuel's Philippe Selendy

FHFA Trial Produces Big Loss for Banks, Big Win for Quinn Emanuel

By Scott Flaherty |

Sullivan & Cromwell and Simpson Thacher couldn't pull off a surprise win before U.S. District Judge Denise Cote.

Programmers and Traders and Dark Pools, Oh My

By David Bario |

The high-frequency trading exploits depicted in Michael Lewis' 2014 bestseller "Flash Boys" were keeping at least three Manhattan judges busy this week.

In Replay of FHFA Appeal, Banks Urge Second Circuit To Topple FDIC Claims

By Scott Flaherty |

Can Sullivan & Cromwell's Bob Giuffra succeed where his predecessors failed?

Barclays Can't Escape 'Dark Pool' Securities Class Action

By Scott Flaherty |

Barclays' lawyers at Sullivan & Cromwell managed to trim but not defeat claims that the bank misled investors about safeguards in its Liquidity Cross dark pool.

Citigroup Can't Dodge Lawsuit Over Soured CDO

By Scott Flaherty |

A financial crisis case that stumbled on South Korean law regained its footing on Wednesday, when a U.S. appeals court revived claims that Citigroup Inc. duped a Korean bank into investing in a complex investment product that went belly-up in the global recession.

Quinn Emanuel Wins Reversal, Revives Suit over $1.5B CDO

By Susan Beck |

In the latest case sparked by the alleged CDO shenanigans of hedge fund Magnetar Capital, the Second Circuit ruled that FGIC can pursue claims over a $1.5 billion CDO gone bad.

Wal-Mart Asks Third Circuit to Holster Gun Sales Proposal

By Scott Flaherty |

Gibson Dunn's Ted Boutrous and Delaware shareholder lawyer Joel Friedlander will square off Wednesday over an unusual proxy proposal challenging Wal-Mart's sales of high capacity guns and other potentially "offensive" products.

U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara speaks at a press conference in early 2014.

No Respite for Gov't as Court Affirms Insider Trading Ruling

By Julie Triedman |

Stephen Fishbein of Shearman & Sterling and Mark Pomerantz of Paul Weiss won't have to reargue the successful appeals of Todd Newman and Anthony Chiasson at the Second Circuit.

Courting Whistleblowers, SEC Targets KBR Secrecy Pacts

By Scott Flaherty |

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission on Wednesday fined technology and engineering company KBR Inc. over confidentiality agreements that, the agency claims, could have silenced potential whistleblowers.

U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission building.

Lynn Tilton, Patriarch Strike Back at SEC Judges

By David Bario |

It didn't take long for "Diva of Distressed" Lynn Tilton and her lawyers at Skadden to take the offensive against the Securities and Exchange Commission.

Skadden's David Zornow.

Skadden to Square Off With SEC in Tilton, Patriarch Drama

By Scott Flaherty |

Last year lawyers at Skadden brought a constitutional challenge against the SEC for filing an unrelated case against an investment adviser as an administrative action rather than a federal lawsuit. Will the firm go on the offensive for the "Diva of Distressed" as well?

Investment Bank Sues Morrison & Foerster Over Puda Coal Debacle

By Scott Flaherty |

The defunct, fraud-addled Chinese company Puda Coal was disaster for its investors, and remains a major litigation headache for its bankers. Now the investment bank Macquarie Group wants the lawyers to share the blame.

$20 Billion Later, Banks Finally Win Ruling on Time Limits

By Scott Flaherty |

Big banks have failed to convince courts around the country that various government agencies waited too long to sue over Wall Street's role in the 2008 financial crisis. This week, a judge finally adopted the banks' reasoning in a case brought by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.

As Settlement Pie Shrinks, Firms Fight for Their Slice

By Scott Flaherty |

After a lackluster year for securities class action settlements, fee awards in deals involving IndyMac and AIG highlight the uncertainties facing plaintiffs firms in even the biggest cases.


Context Is King in Supreme Court's Omnicare Ruling

By David Bario |

The justices held that Omnicare can't be held liable under Section 11 of the Securities Act of 1933 just because it offered opinions in a regulatory filing that turned out to be false. But they also said couching a statement as an opinion is no magic bullet for securities defendants.

Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine.

Lawyers Eye Fees in BNY Mellon Deal as Ohio Mulls Reforms

By Susan Beck |

Lieff Cabraser and another outside law firm stand to earn $43 million from Ohio's portion of a $714 million settlement with The Bank of New York Mellon. But even though Ohio's attorney general signed off on the contingency deal, he's backing a bill that would have made it impossible.

Skadden Partner Turned Bank Foe Can't Challenge JPMorgan Deal

By Scott Flaherty |

Dennis Kelleher, the former Skadden partner-turned Wall Street watchdog, hit a litigation dead end this week in his crusade for financial reform.

Irving Picard

Picard Taps SCOTUS Pro for Swipe at Madoff 'Net Winners'

By Scott Flaherty |

Irving Picard has hit a wall in his efforts to claw back nearly $2 billion in "fictitious" profits pocketed by Bernie Madoff's customers. Can Goldstein & Russell's Thomas Goldstein succeed where Picard's partners at Baker & Hostetler have failed?

Wachtell Knocks Out Shareholder Suit Over Avon Bribes Probe

By Scott Flaherty |

The firm helped shield Avon Products Inc. from more fallout over allegations that the cosmetics company bribed officials in a half-dozen foreign countries, convincing a judge in Manhattan to toss shareholder derivative claims related to the long-simmering bribery flap.

U.S. District Judge Thomas Griesa

BlackBerry Dodges Another Securities Class Action Bullet

By Scott Flaherty |

BlackBerry Ltd. may still be grasping at the heels of its smartphone competitors, but the company's lawyers aren't having much trouble beating back investor class actions over its spotty performance.

FHFA, Nomura Head to Trial Over Fannie and Freddie Losses

By Julie Triedman |

After four years of courtroom wrangling and more than $20 billion in settlements, the first trial is set to begin Monday in the Federal Housing Finance Agency's litigation campaign against banks that packaged and sold mortgage-backed securities.

U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission building in Washington, D.C.

SEC Wins Appeal in Fight with Pre-Dodd-Frank Whistleblower

By Scott Flaherty |

The Second Circuit on Wednesday lowered the chances that "zombie" whistleblowers who offered their tips to the SEC before Dodd-Frank will ever see a reward.